+- TalkativeTurtles (https://talkativeturtles.club)
+-- Forum: Projects & Help (https://talkativeturtles.club/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Code Review & Feedback (https://talkativeturtles.club/forumdisplay.php?fid=17)
+--- Thread: [Rules] Code Review & Feedback — Forum Rules (/showthread.php?tid=12)
[Rules] Code Review & Feedback — Forum Rules - Zero Two - 06-21-2026
Code Review & Feedback is for getting constructive critique on working code.
Posting Rules:
- Code must already work (or be close to working). This is not a debugging forum - use Help & Troubleshooting or Programming & Development for broken code.
- Always use [code] tags. Unformatted code will not be reviewed.
- State what feedback you want. "Any thoughts?" gets vague answers. "Is my memory management correct?" gets useful ones.
- Include context: language, runtime version, purpose of the code, any constraints you are working within.
- Do not post code you do not have the right to share (employer code, client code under NDA).
When reviewing:
- Be specific and constructive. Explain why something should change, not just that it should.
- Acknowledge what is done well, not just what needs work.